Shameful! The Dept. of Veterans snubs South African military sacrifice

The article in the Sunday Times, today 17 February 2019 is simply shameful and outrageous, on the Front page and Page 6 it makes for very grim and sad reading for any statutory force military veteran.  It’s utterly unacceptable and the Department of Veterans needs to be held account by the veterans fraternity they serve for their revolutionist history which discredits all military service and sacrifice of South African statutory forces pre 1994, including those of the SS Mendi.

In addition, the wholesale discrediting of the Gunners Association because of ‘colonial’ origins has ramifications for all veteran associations under the Council of Military Veterans (CMVO) in South Africa, including the South African Legion and the Memorable Order of Tin Hats whose origins date back to World War 1.

SALegion_FinalLogoLayout_GreenPrintTextOn the other hand, in my capacity as President of the South African Legion England branch, I am assured that the South African Legion of Military Veterans, as a charity organisation concerned with Remembrance will continue to remember the fallen of all South African military personnel irrespective of race, gender or historical epoch and irrespective of the views presented by South Africa’s Department of Veterans in the article today.

The South African Legion also remains committed to the SS Mendi Remembrance Parades and Services, having just completed a Mendi Memorial service at Avalon yesterday – without the inclusion of The Department of Veterans.

The South African Legion will continue to remember this tragedy in history which suffered so much dishonour and disrespect for politically expediency in the past and now may even stand to suffer the same dishonour by the current government going forward.

We need to truly evaluate our values as South Africans.  The South Africans lost on the SS Mendi suffered the indignity of South African ‘white’ politicians once, it is simply inconceivable that they may suffer the same indignity again – only this time its been done by the African National Congress and its government organs.

Titled “Veterans snub SS Mendi heroes” and written by Bobby Jordan it makes for infuriating reading – here it is:


17 February 2019 

Veterans snub SS Mendi heroes

By Bobby Jordan

“More than 600 mainly black South African soldiers died in a World War 1 shipping accident but the department of military veterans says it will no longer honour them because they were involved in an “imperial” war.


Mbulelo Musi.of the Dept of Veterans

The department has previously supported annual Gunners Association commemoration ceremonies at the SS Mendi memorial in Cape Town. But no more. “We can’t be encouraging an approach that says we still belong to an imperial past,” said department spokesperson Mbulelo Musi.

Kevin Ashton, the chair of the Gunners Association, said the decision — which means there will be no formal military presence at Sunday’s memorial — was an insult to the descendants of the 646 Mendi dead,

The department of military veterans has withdrawn support for an “imperial” commemoration of a World War 1 shipping disaster in which 646 mainly black South Africans died. The department said this week it would not take part in the annual commemoration of the SS Mendi sinking.


The annual ceremony, organised by the Gunners Association, is due to take place on Sunday at the SS Mendi memorial in Cape Town, just three days after President Cyril Ramaphosa visits the same site for a separate Armed Forces Day ceremony.

The Gunners Association event has previously enjoyed support from the department of military veterans and the South African National Defence Force, but it has now been labelled politically incorrect.

Department spokesperson Mbulelo Musi said it had decided to support only “unified” ceremonies that did not involve formations rooted in the imperial and apartheid past, such as the Gunners Association.

‘Wars of colonialism’

“Now in a democratic dispensation, we can’t be encouraging an approach that says we still belong to an imperial past,” he said. “It cannot be, for it defeats the purpose of what our democratic government stands for, which is reconciliation, social cohesion and nation building.” Musi said both world wars were “wars of colonialism” that had little to do with SA’s democratic freedom. “Colonialism was by nature divisive — it is the opposite of what we stand for as South Africans post-’94,” Musi said. “We must therefore be very sensitive to these matters.” Musi said the department would take part in Armed Forces Day on Thursday “in the spirit of trying to say we are all together. It is unfortunate that people move outside the efforts of the nation.”

Dept-of-military-veteransKevin Ashton, chairman of the Gunners Association Western Cape branch, said the decision was an unfortunate break from tradition and an insult to the families of the deceased.
A department staffer informed him of the decision in a phone call two weeks ago. “He said the DMV will not support colonial memorials. I said, ‘what are you talking about?’,” Ashton said, adding that the Mendi commemoration was a deeply symbolic event. He said the department also withdrew support for.last year’s Cape Town commemoration of the 1916 Battle of Delville Wood, in which about 2,500 South Africans died in France during World War 1.

No military bands

A retired senior military officer this week described the department’s decision as “abominable and a disgrace”. He said: “This means no military band or guards in fact no formal military presence at a memorial for South Africans who died on service in war.”
But Musi insisted the department’s intention was not to dishonour victims but to avoid “reopening old wounds”.


In Conclusion

There will no doubt be reactions to this Sunday Times article and accompanying it will be a stream of deniability, retraction and ‘misinterpretation’ of a ANC government spokesperson.  However the truth is it happens time and again, be under no disillusion, the ANC is insidiously and consistently eroding South Africa’s military history which is inconsistent with their own political rhetoric.  There is an ongoing campaign to discredit all veterans who served in South African military units prior to 1994 and their long-standing veteran organisations – and it extends to both the war dead and memorials to them.

It’s a foreboding and bleak future for military veterans who fought and died in South African wars prior to 1994 i.e WW1, WW2, Korean War and the Border War.  The inconvenient truth is that their sacrifice is South Africa’s modern liberty. It is a warning of things to come if not challenged now – and the ANC government and Department of Veterans should heed this famous quote by George Santayana;

“Those who do not remember the past are condemned to repeat it”.

Posted for the Observation Post by Peter Dickens – extract and reference “Sunday Time, 17 February 2019 Veterans snub SS Mendi heroes By Bobby Jordan

Related Observation Post Links:

SS Mendi: Let us die like brothers … the silent voices of the SS Mendi finally heard

South African Navy Sacrifice Ignored: The South African Navy’s ‘elephant in the room’

5 thoughts on “Shameful! The Dept. of Veterans snubs South African military sacrifice

  1. Well said, Peter.

    Perhaps Mr Mbulelo Musi needs to be reminded of the ‘imperial past’ of the regimes of Joe Stalin and Chairman Mao and their successors. One thinks, without any effort, of Hungary, Czechoslovakia, Tianmin Square and the present-day fate of the Uighurs, all of which have enjoyed a taste of Soviet and Chinese imperialism. It so happens, too, that the ANC’s own ‘soldiers’ received their much vaunted military training in Moscow’s and Beijing’s versions of Sandhurst. Some people either have short memories or closed minds.


  2. Fighting against tyranny and for one’s country is not fighting for imperialism. It is rooted in patriotism, high principles, decency, courage and honour. Those concepts are obviously foreign to many ANC members who can only recite the revolutionary rhetoric taught to those unable to think for themselves.


  3. As a veteran myself I would remind The Veterans that The Madiba said that South Africans should look towards peace and understanding. South Africa has survived Apartheid which was in itself disgusting and reprehensible but our & the World’s history does not simply begin when that period started or indeed ended. For instance, during the Second World War, the efforts to deliver foodstuffs & weaponry to the Soviet nation during the Murmansk Convoys and others should be taken especial heed of by the Veterans who were trained there and if they respect the Russian nation which provided them with succour then they should consider that there was a possibility that the Union of Soviet Socialist Republics might not have prevailed as quickly as they did or at all had they not received Sherman tanks, Bell P39 fighters and other war material from the Western Allies. Men died for a cause which they believed in. If can concede this then they should also concede that the efforts African volunteers who perished in the SS Mendhi during WW1 should also be paid respect to. This is a part of history and if they are capable of having conceded these facts then they should spare a thought for those others in South Africa who served for a cause as they did. That cause was World Freedom. The Madiba called for peace and understanding. Understanding what our fellow South Africans view as worthy of respect should be part of that. Well, I wrote this from the heart without corrections but I hope the sentiment comes through.


  4. Musi clearly has no idea what would have become of Africans had Nazi Germany and fascist Italy won World War 2, but here’s a clue: Hitler called black people untermenschen (subhumans) and his South African supporters, the Ossewa Brandwag (OB), were helping him and waiting to do his bidding in the event of an Axis victory. Vorster was an OB “general”. Hey, why don’t we quit the Commonwealth because of its imperialistic origins? The people who work for this government are so embarrassing.


  5. the ANC and the dept of Military Veterans must Remember that the freedom to make this distgusting statement is only because the allies won the second world war ; Had Hitler won none of the ANC would be here today thier mothers and siblings would have gone to the Gas chambers . thier Fathers and older Brothers would have been in slave labour camps and worked to Death we all know what Hitler thought of the African.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.